Direct Beneficiary Designation – RRSP or RRIF

Written by Shannon Warawa, CPA, CA on Jul. 11, 2017

If you are considering a direct beneficiary designation for either a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) or a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF), you should be aware of some negative consequences that can occur.

A direct beneficiary designation can result in unintended tax consequences to the estate, the inequitable treatment of heirs or the distribution of your estate in a manner different from your intentions.  But a little advance planning could help avoid these problems.

Unintended Tax Consequences

If you have designated a beneficiary on your RRSP or RRIF, the entire value of it will be paid directly to that designated beneficiary.  No tax will be withheld on the funds transferred.  However, you or your estate will be deemed to have disposed of all your assets at fair market value.

your estate will be responsible for paying any resulting taxes

This means that the entire fair market value of your registered investment will be included on your terminal personal tax return and your estate will be responsible for paying any resulting taxes owing even though the cash is now in the hands of your beneficiary.

If your RRSP or RRIF is paid to a qualified beneficiary, the tax can be deferred if your beneficiary transfers the funds to another registered investment but if they do not qualify then significant taxes can result.  Qualified beneficiaries include your spouse, common-law spouse or a financially dependent child or grandchild.

Treatment of Heirs

Depending on the assets you hold when you die, designating a beneficiary to your RRSP or RRIF can also result in the inequitable treatment of your heirs.  For example, John has three children, Jack, Jill and Tom, and no surviving spouse.  He wants each child to inherit an equal portion of his estate.  When John dies, his assets are comprised of a $100,000 RRSP and $200,000 of non-registered investments with a $100,000 capital gain.  John designated Jack under the direct beneficiary designation of the RRSP and Jill and Tom will receive the rest of his estate.

In his designation of Jack as the beneficiary of the RRSP, John overlooked that there would be no tax withheld on the payment of the RRSP to Jack and also that his estate would be responsible for the tax liability on the RRSP as well as on the capital gain on the non-registered investment.

The tax on the $100,000 of income from John’s RRSP and the $50,000 of taxable capital gain on the non-registered investment will be reported as income on John’s terminal personal tax return.  Assuming a marginal tax rate of 40%, the taxes owing will be $60,000.  Jill and Tom will receive a net amount of $140,000 to split between the two of them or $70,000 each while Jack will inherit $100,000.

Distribution of Assets

you may lose the ability to impose your wishes

If you have a blended family, then designating your RRSP or RRIF directly to your spouse may not achieve the result you want.  If you would like to provide an ongoing income to your surviving spouse for the remainder of their lifetime, but prefer to leave the underlying assets to your children upon your spouse’s death, then you should consider paying the RRSP or RRIF to your estate rather than designating your spouse under the direct beneficiary designation.  If your spouse inherits the RRSP or RRIF by direct beneficiary designation you lose the ability to impose your wishes on when and how it is used.

There are many instances when the direct beneficiary designation on your RRSP or RRIF will not result in the outcome you desire.  Use discretion when making this decision and talk to your financial advisor and accountant for further information and advice.

If you would like more information or have any questions, feel free to contact us at 780.466.6204, or click here to send us an email.

Thanks to Shannon Warawa of KWB Chartered Professional Accountants for providing this content.

Shannon Warawa, CPA, CA

Shannon Warawa, CPA, CA

Accountant

Shannon Warawa joined KWB in September 2005. Shannon received her Bachelor of Commerce from the University of Alberta in 1999. After articling with PricewaterhouseCoopers for three years, she was employed with Howard Kirkpatrick Associates during which time she obtained her C.A. designation. She marked practice questions for the 2004 Uniform Evaluation. In 2017, her name was added to the coveted Bunnock trophy when her team took 1st place in KWB’s 10th Annual Bunnock Tournament.

Shannon works part-time, is married and has 3 children. Away from work, she enjoys camping trips with her family, reading, attending her children’s basketball, hockey and lacrosse games. She has also been the volunteer Treasurer on the Parent Council of her children’s elementary school for the last number of years.

Shannon's Contact Information

Other Posts by Shannon

Feb 19 2015
US Tax Filing

Are you a US citizen? Do you spend more than 120 days per year in the US? If so you may be required to file a US personal tax return.

Mar 21 2017
CRA Fraud Protection

Canada Revenue Agency and police again warned taxpayers of randomly targeted fraudulent telephone calls and e-mails that are being sent out as CRA fraud.  These phone calls and e-mails are not from the CRA. Annually the number of CRA fraud scams rise near the April 30th tax deadline. The phone call scams are imposters trying

Aug 11 2015
Applying for a trust account number or asking for a clearance certificate

Applying for a trust account number Trustees can apply for a trust account number before filing their T3RET, T3 Trust Income Tax and Information Return. Trust account numbers start with the letter “T” and are followed by an eight-digit number. You can use Form T3 APP, Application for Trust Account Number to apply for a

Apr 26 2016
Estate Planning Gifting Strategy

An estate planning gifting strategy is basically when you start to give away some of your assets prior to death in order to optimize taxes within the family. Usually, an estate planning gifting strategy refers to how we will distribute our assets when we die.  But you might be overlooking significant tax savings by not

Aug 30 2016
Graduated Rate Estates – New Rules for 2016

Starting for 2016 taxation years, inter vivos trusts, trusts created by will and certain estates will be subject to the top taxation rate. There are two exceptions to this change: graduated rate estates and qualified disability trusts. Graduated tax rates will still apply to these types of estates and trusts. Income earned and retained in

Nov 15 2016
Top 4 Financial Tips for the New Parent

Here are our top 4 financial tips for the new parent: Apply for a Social Insurance Number (SIN) for your child: It’s a good idea for you to apply for a Social Insurance Number for your child as soon as they are born. This way, you will not be left scrambling to obtain one when your

Mar 28 2017
EI, OAS and CPP Rulings

Employment and Social Development Canada (“ESDC”) is responsible for EI, OAS and CPP rulings, not Canada Revenue Agency. On April 1, 2013, the Social Security Tribunal (“SST”), an independent administrative tribunal operating at arm’s length from ESDC, was introduced to review appeals on EI, OAS and CPP rulings made by the ESDC. The process to

Jan 16 2018
Advance Income Tax Rulings

Advance Income Tax Rulings are written statements providing assurance on the income tax treatment of a specific proposed transaction or transactions that you might be contemplating. Subject to any disclaimer or qualification stated in the ruling, the ruling is considered binding with respect to the specific taxpayer making the request and the specific proposed transaction

Aug 7 2018
Form T1135 Foreign Income

Form T1135 Foreign Income Verification Statement must be filed if you, your corporation, trust or partnership, owned or held foreign property with a cost amount of more than $100,000 at any time in the year even if some or all of the property was sold before the year of the year. The form is

Sep 11 2018
Receipt Bank

If you would like to spend less time on data entry and more time growing your business, you should automate your bookkeeping with Receipt Bank. Receipt Bank is a website application that extracts key information from your invoices and receipts and publishes it directly into Quickbooks Online (QBO). Integrates with QBO You can submit invoices